CFBMManagement Services
Business

Gross or Net? Why Two Agencies Quoting 40% Can Charge Very Different Amounts

A percentage is not a price until you know what it is calculated on. The one multiplier that makes any two agency quotes comparable.

The short answer

A percentage is not a price until you know what it is calculated on. On a platform that keeps 20% of everything, a 40% rate taken on gross and a 50% rate taken on net cost almost exactly the same. The agency quoting the lower number is not necessarily cheaper, and in this market it is often the one that looks cheaper on purpose.

What gross and net actually mean here

Gross is what subscribers pay. Net is what lands in your balance after the platform has taken its own cut, which on OnlyFans and Fansly is 20% of essentially everything: subscriptions, tips, pay-per-view, the lot.

So on $10,000 of gross sales, the platform takes $2,000 and $8,000 reaches you. That $8,000 is net. An agency percentage can be applied to either figure, and nothing in the phrase "we take 40%" tells you which.

The same account, two ways of quoting it

Take that $10,000 gross month. An agency charging 40% on gross bills $4,000, leaving you $4,000 once the platform has taken its $2,000. An agency charging 50% on net bills 50% of $8,000, which is $4,000, leaving you $4,000.

Identical outcome, and a ten point gap in the headline figure. Now run it the other way. A 40% net rate on the same month bills $3,200 and leaves you $4,800. That is $800 a month better than the 40% gross quote, from two agencies advertising the same number.

The arithmetic is not complicated. It is just that the important half of it is usually left out of the sentence.

Converting between the two

Where the platform keeps 20%, multiply a gross rate by 1.25 to get the equivalent net rate. A 40% gross rate is a 50% net rate. A 30% gross rate is 37.5% net. Divide instead to go the other way: a 50% net rate is 40% gross.

That one multiplier makes any two quotes comparable, which is the only reason to bother with it. Put both into net and the cheaper one is simply the smaller number.

What the rate leaves out matters as much

Once both quotes are in the same units, the next question is scope, and it is usually where the larger difference hides.

The inbox is the item to check first. Messaging is the largest revenue line on most subscription accounts and the biggest share of the hours, so an agency that quotes for running the account and prices the messaging separately has quoted for the smaller half of the work. Two rates that look identical are not comparable if one covers the messages and the other does not.

Then check for a pay-per-view cut on top of the headline rate. A percentage of the account plus a further percentage of PPV sales is effectively a higher rate, expressed in a way that makes the first number look reasonable.

Then the extras. Traffic work, content protection and takedowns, link pages, and anything billed as onboarding or optimisation. None of those are unreasonable to charge for, and all of them should be visible before you sign rather than appearing on an invoice in month three.

Why so little of it is published

Most agencies in this market will not give a figure before a call. The usual explanation is that scope varies, which is true as far as it goes. The less flattering explanation is that a number settled in conversation can be adjusted to the person in it, and a number on a website cannot.

That is worth knowing rather than being cynical about. It means the first figure you are quoted is frequently an opening position, and it means a creator who has done the gross-to-net conversion before the call is negotiating from a different place than one who has not.

The questions that make a quote comparable

Four of them, and all four belong in writing.

Is the percentage on gross or on net. Does it include the messaging. Is there any cut of pay-per-view on top of it. What else is billed separately, and at what rate.

With those answered you can put two agencies side by side honestly. Without them you are comparing a number to a different number that happens to be written the same way.

What we do

Ours is quoted on net and published on the catalogue rather than held back for a call, and the rate covers running the account and answering the inbox together. There is no messaging surcharge and no cut of pay-per-view on top.

That is not a claim to be the cheapest, and for a creator who wants every service at once it may well not be. It is that the figure is comparable to anyone else's before you speak to us, which is the part of this the market mostly does not offer.

Comments

Comments are read before they appear. No account, no email address, no cookie.

Want your account run properly?

We run OnlyFans and Fansly accounts end to end, posting and inbox on one published rate. No messaging surcharge, and the figure is on the site rather than behind a call.

See how it works and what it costs